My Problem with Gratitude

It feels quite superficial and performative, ignoring the transformative reality of the hard thing.

Happy Friday Eve. Whenever and wherever you are in the world, I hope you can take three deep breaths, and a moment to enjoy that ‘we made it’ feeling of Friday eve.

One of the practices we are constantly urged to put in place is ‘gratitude’. It seems to be the one thing that crosses all creeds. If you want to be happy, each day, write three things that you are grateful for and watch how it changes your life.

I have never been able to consistently practice this. I can do it for a day when I’m motivated, but the next day comes and I’ve completely forgotten about my new goal. While it’s natural for me to free write in my journal multiple days a week, pull an oracle or tarot card to reflect on, and wake up at 4am to get my writing in…gratitude? Never been natural, nor a habit I’ve been able to build. Which is a bit silly because there is plenty in my life that I am grateful for. This week, however, I think I finally figured out why gratitude as a practice is just so hard for me.

Gratitude bypasses the hard stuff.

When I was in my 200 hour Yoga Teacher Training in 2017-2018, one of our required texts was The Untethered Soul. Most everyone in my class loved this book, but I hated it. (And I think I disappointed the teacher by saying so. Anyway.) While I don’t remember much of the specifics of this book, I vividly remember getting angry as it described the need, essentially, to let go of all of your emotions, to detach completely. Somehow, in order to find…I don’t even remember what. Peace? Harmony? You had to stop feeling. That answer continues to baffle me.

Emotions are a core part of who I am. Feeling them, recognizing them, journaling and understanding them. How can you learn anything about yourself without feeling the emotion first? That book invalidated everything I had been through and it just felt plain wrong to try and follow its teachings.

Gratitude, I think, appears to act in the same way. To just list a few things each day for which I’m grateful seems equivalent to spiritual bypassing. Sure, I'll have a beautiful list detailing wonderful people, places and experiences, but it feels superficial. It gives off ‘good vibes only’. (Gross.)

What about the struggles I had that day? The anxieties that nearly stopped me, or did stop me? The dumb little things that never go right? Or that thing I completely screwed up? If I were to ignore all of this and just say “oh I’m grateful for…”, that gunk would just build up inside me. It may stay stuck, act as stress, and manifest as physical pain. Or it’ll burst out of me at the worst possible moment. Either way, it cannot be ignored with gratitude acting as a bandaid.

We cannot have the good without the bad. They are interlocked so intricately that to ignore one is to minimize the other. I need something more if gratitude is going to work for me.

A Minor Success

There was a short lived time where I was able to practice gratitude almost daily. I bought a gratitude notebook and was determined. For a little over a month in the summer of 2024, I wrote something most days of the week. I do remember feeling grateful (haha) for the practice because I noticed how much better I felt. One day, I realized that I was laughing, that I was feeling again. I wasn’t numbing out anymore. The practice brought me out of a depressive low. But my gratitude practice fell off quickly after that realization. I couldn’t pinpoint quite what stopped it, but it’s two years later and I’m still searching for the way, any way, to make gratitude a practice. I know it works, but I need something better.

We’re not skipping the hard stuff

Here’s my new plan.

Each day, from now until the Winter Solstice, I want to track the things I’m grateful for.

And/but first.

I want to write down the hard thing(s) that is stopping me from being grateful. I’m hoping by acknowledging the difficulty with whatever I’m experiencing first, it’ll then allow me to explore something I’m grateful for, related or not. The first part is easy for me, so maybe I can just tack on the gratitude piece, too.

I want to make gratitude a practice in my life. I know there is strong science around how it is beneficial for us. But I need to do it in a way that makes sense to me, in a way that doesn’t feel performative, or as if I’m wearing rose-colored glasses.

Habits take effort. Motivation doesn’t get you places, discipline does, and accountability is a huge help. Expect a few check ins along the way and we’ll see if I can make this gratitude thing work. For me.

Tell Me Something Good

I’m going to end here and notice a moment of irony. The last couple years, as a teacher, when I walk into my class and I am going through it, I do not start with my lesson. I look at my students and say, ‘tell me something good.’ I tell them that I’m struggling and that I need some uplifting thoughts. Most of them start sharing something good, big or small, and within a few minutes, we’re all laughing. I’m much calmer and on better footing to start the lesson.

While my own gratitude isn’t something natural for me, hearing others’ snaps me out of my funk. So, on this Friday eve, or whenever you’re reading this, I would so appreciate you telling me something good. I’d love to celebrate with you.

I’ll go first: As a girl with social anxiety, going into crowded spaces alone is a challenge for me, to say the least. I'm incredibly grateful that I pushed past this in July to go to a château in the South of France to meet some of the most phenomenal women ever. More on that next week.

View of the Pyrenees Mountains from the dance & yoga studio in the château.

Previous
Previous

The Magic of a Château

Next
Next

Reading Roundup