Hear me out as we’re all in our rereading preparations. Note ‘rereading’. This is NOT a spoiler-free zone.
Much like all of my fellow Maasverse fans, I’m in the middle of rereading the ACOTAR (A Court of Thrones and Roses) series prior to book 6 coming out in October (and 7 coming out in January.)
I put off reading this series for so long until the urging of my sister who was not a reader at the time. For my initial 3-star review from Goodreads from a few years ago, I wrote:
It was fine. A beauty and the beast retelling of sorts, but unbalanced pacing. Very slow until about 75% of the way through then a mix of too fast and too slow. If you’re a fantasy person or a romance person, probably right up your alley. Curious where the next ones will go.
And we all know where the next ones go.
Vital information:
I am a Nesta stan through and through and I’m not looking forward to dealing with Feyre for 2+ more books during this reread. I am praying we get more Nesta in the new ones.
If she and Cassian aren’t happily ever after, I will not be okay.
I ADORE A Court of Frost and Starlight and I’m absolutely convinced that this book gives us so many easter eggs of what is to come. I do not get how people skip or hate this.
Back to the boringness of Feyre…
I want to say that after reading it multiple times, I now disagree with the pacing being too fast and too slow. It is an atypical pace, though. It took a long time for that girl to get Under the Mountain, so that could’ve been sped up some.
Time and time again I was so surprised about Feyre’s arrogance. Her complete lack of fear? understanding? awareness? of her humanness while in Prythian, thinking she was eavesdropping without them knowing, all the sounds she heard but didn’t see anyone in the manor, or, my favorite, that she would somehow be the one to find the escape route that none of the other High Lords found while she was down there. Her tenacity and her grit were clearly what pushed her through and saved her, and both clearly admirable. Maybe it’s her delusion that I was frustrated with?
My boredom grew in tandem with how much she focused on her goal to save Tamlin. I guess that’s the immaturity of it, young first love. I wanted to skim over the pages any time she focused there instead of ‘hey you are actually saving all of the Fae so maybe use that a little bit more for your motivation?’ Especially given he wasn’t doing much. I remember this same feeling during my first read.
And then how perfect Feyre feels. I think that’s part of what draws me to Nesta. That girl is not perfect and she doesn’t pretend to be. Feyre has that energy of “I can do no wrong” and it irks me. Her flaws aren’t explored. Her belief she isn’t pretty enough or anything sure, but her character flaws (which we all have) are never an arc with her. Perfect. Boring.
I’ve already started ACOMAF and holy damn do I hate how she cowers to Tamlin with the dresses and such. I get the needed contrast but I am very excited to her finding some fire. Naturally, I’m binging and I’m going to start chapter 42 today when they go to A Court of Nightmares.
((A funny note though…I finally got why they call it ‘A Court of Dreams’…yes it took me that long…))
I am appreciating her healing arc, especially as she’s starting to see some of her own actions in Rhys. Maas was very artful and true in the way she emphasized anger being a good thing for Feyre, how her lack of noticing color to the names of paintings finally coming to her again, her realization that while it was love, it may have just been because Tamlin was the first who loved her, but there is more out there.
Feyre has always been determined to stand on her own two feet, to survive. Her drive to do what is right coincides with a natural arrogance there, a righteousness. Rhys has the same vibe, though he’s aware of it, more open about it. He also has the internal conflict of holding to the narrative that’s been built around him versus showing his truth.
Compared to everyone else, there’s an emptiness here with Feyre. I suppose her healing, coming into her role as High Lady, from weak mortal to strongest high fae is her arc. I’m hoping she’s limited in the new books, and we get more of Elain. (And please, not Elain and Azriel…) Once I finish the reread I think I’ll make a post of all my predictions/hopes. Would love to hear all your theories too!
Happy rereading<3
